Wise men came from the east looking for a child. They told King Herod they had seen the child's star. The Gospel of Matthew tells the story in Greek.
Where is he that is born King of the Jews? for we have seen his star in the east, and are come to worship him. (Matthew 2:2)
The Greek word in Matthew is simply star. He gives no shape. He never says it had five points or six points or any points at all. Every Christmas card with a pointed star on it is somebody's drawing, made long after Matthew.
That matters, because people argue about star shapes and assume the Bible settled the question. It never did.
The star in the old books
There is an older star in the Bible, and it doesn't have a shape either.
It comes from many centuries before Jesus. Balaam was a prophet from outside Israel. The king of Moab, a neighboring kingdom, hired him to curse Israel. Instead Balaam blessed them, and said a star would come out of Jacob.
The Hebrew word is kokhav, star, and once again nothing says how many points it had. Jacob was the ancestor Israel was named after, so a star out of Jacob meant a leader coming from that family. Many Jewish readers took it as a promise of a coming king. About a hundred years after Jesus, a man led a revolt against Rome. His followers called him Bar Kokhba, which means "son of the star," because they thought he was the one that blessing promised. The revolt failed.
In both of these passages the star is a way of talking about a person. Neither one is a symbol you could draw.
The five-pointed star
People sometimes say the five-pointed star stands for the crucifixion of Jesus. The honest answer is that this was never a widespread Christian belief.
The shape is far older than Christianity. It turns up in some of the oldest writing in the world, and much later a group of Greek thinkers used it as a sign of good health.
There is one famous Christian use of it, in an English poem from the 1300s about a knight named Gawain. His shield carries a five-pointed star. The poet explains that the five points stand for five sets of five things. One of them is the five wounds Christ received on the cross. Another is five joys Mary had in her son. The poet also calls the shape a sign of King Solomon and of faithfulness.
So in that one well-known case, the five wounds are part of the meaning. The star is not a picture of the crucifixion. And in the last few hundred years, occult groups adopted the same shape, which is why many Christians today are uneasy about it.
The six-pointed star
The six-pointed star is known today as the Star of David, and it is the main symbol of the Jewish people. Most people assume it comes from the Bible. It doesn't.
The phrase "Star of David" never appears in the Hebrew Bible. For most of history this shape was simply a decoration, used by many peoples, including Christians in their churches and Muslims in their art. In medieval stories both the five-pointed and the six-pointed shape were called the "Seal of Solomon," and people used the two shapes interchangeably.
There was never a moment when one shape turned into the other. They were used side by side for centuries.
The six-pointed star became the special sign of the Jewish people only in the last few hundred years. It spread among Jewish communities in the 1600s and 1700s and became the standard emblem in the 1800s. In 1897 it went on the flag of a new movement to give Jews a homeland of their own, and in 1948 on the flag of Israel. In between came the worst use of it in history, when Jews were forced to wear it as a yellow badge so they could be singled out and killed. When people use this symbol as an insult, that history is why it hurts.
The crescent
The crescent moon is the shape most people now link with Islam. Muslims themselves are often the first to point out that it isn't a religious symbol.
The Qur'an does not make the crescent a sign of the faith, and the earliest Muslims did not use it on their banners. What the Qur'an, Islam's holy book, does talk about is the new moon, as a way of telling time. Each Islamic month begins when the first thin crescent is seen. That includes the month of fasting, which Muslims call Ramadan. That is a calendar, not an emblem.
The crescent-and-star became tied to Islam mainly through the Ottoman Empire, a Turkish empire that ruled much of the Middle East for centuries, which put it on its flags. Nations that came out of that world kept it. Where the Ottomans got it is still debated. There is a popular story that they took it from Constantinople when they conquered the city, but that is not established, and crescents appear on older objects from several places. We are not going to repeat it as fact.
Is there a crescent in the Bible?
Yes, in two places, and neither has anything to do with Islam.
The first one comes from Israel's story before it had kings. Gideon was one of those leaders, called judges, who defended Israel before it had kings. After he defeated the kings of Midian, a people to the east, he took the moon-shaped ornaments that hung on their camels' necks. Later, the women of Jerusalem wore the same kind of crescent jewelry.
The Hebrew word there means little moons. They were jewelry. About two thousand years separate them from the flag of the Ottoman Empire, and nothing connects the two. Anyone who tells you those camel ornaments are an early version of Islam's symbol is telling you something false.
The Bible does say something about the moon itself. Moses' law warns people not to look up at the sun, the moon and the stars and end up worshiping them.
That warning was about treating lights in the sky as gods. It isn't about any group's flag.
What this tells us
Every shape in this teaching came from people. A poet gave a knight a five-pointed shield. A persecuted community turned a common decoration into its badge, and later a flag. An empire put a crescent on its banners. Then people treated each one as if it had always meant that, and some have fought over them.
The Bible's own stars don't have shapes. Matthew's star led to a child. Balaam's star meant a person who would come from Jacob's family. In both places the star pointed past itself.
That is the pattern this whole curriculum keeps finding. People draw the lines, give the lines meaning, and then treat the meaning as if it came from God. The star in Matthew had no points. It led the wise men to a baby born in a small town, and a baby cannot belong to one side.
If you have ever been made to feel like an outsider because of a symbol, or been taught to fear someone else's, that was a hard thing to carry, and you were right to feel it was wrong. The shapes were drawn by people. The one the star led to belongs to everyone.
Sit with us a while. Nothing here costs anything.